Solution for Section 10.2 Question 8

8. Recall that a relation R on a set A is transitive if, and only if, for all x, y and zin.jpg (595 bytes)A,  if  x R y  and y R z,  then  x R z.

Consider the statement If R is transitive then R-1 is transitive.

The contrapositive of this statement is If R-1 is not transitive then R is not transitive.

Suppose that the relation R-1 on a set A is not transitive. So there exist elements x, y and zin.jpg (595 bytes)A,  such that   (x,y) in.jpg (595 bytes) R-1,   (y,z) in.jpg (595 bytes) R-1 and   x is not related to z by R-1.
Then in R, we must have   (y,x) in.jpg (595 bytes) R,   (z,y) in.jpg (595 bytes) R and z is not related to x by R.
Thus R is not transitive.

Therefore, by a proof by contraposition we have shown that   If R is transitive then R-1 is transitive.

Back to Section 10.2